Who voted to overturn roe: Roe v. Wade was a historic judgement that gave constitutional protections for abortions across the nation for nearly half a century. On Friday, the United States Supreme Court voted to overturn Roe v. Wade, leaving the power to regulate abortion to the individual states.
The Supreme Court decided by a vote of 5-4 to overturn Roe v. Wade and by a vote of 6-3 to maintain an abortion ban from Mississippi that was being challenged in the case. Roughly half of the states in the United States have already signalled that they intend to pursue legislation to outlaw the surgery.
Justices Breyer, Kagan, and Sotomayor expressed concern that overturning Roe v. Wade could put other favourable judgments of the Supreme Court, such as those regarding homosexual rights and possibly even contraception, in jeopardy.
The majority’s decision “eliminates a constitutional privilege that has been in place for half a century and that protects women’s freedom and equal position,” “according to their contrary opinion. “It violates a fundamental concept of the rule of law, which is supposed to encourage consistency in the legal system. When all of this is done, it puts other rights, such as same-sex intimacy and marriage, in peril. Contraception is just one of those rights. And finally, it calls into question the legitimacy of the Court.”
In the majority decision that he wrote, Justice Samuel Alito stated that “Roe was egregiously erroneous from the beginning.” “The logic behind it was extremely lacking, and the decisions that it led to having had negative repercussions. And rather than bringing about a national settlement of the abortion problem, the Roe v. Wade decision and the subsequent Casey decision have inflamed discussion and entrenched division.”
The decision to overturn Roe was approved by a vote of 5-4. Justices Stephen Breyer, Sonia Sotomayor, and Elena Kagan harshly criticised the majority opinion in a joint dissenting opinion, which they concluded with the following statement: “With sorrow — for this Court, but more so, for the many millions of American women who have today lost a fundamental constitutional protection — we dissent.”
According to the Guttmacher Institute, which is in favour of abortion rights, at least 21 states currently have legislation or constitutional changes in place that would make it certain for them to attempt to outlaw abortion as swiftly as possible. These laws and amendments are already in place. In addition, it is quite likely that a further four states will join Texas in outlawing abortions as quickly as possible if they are not protected by federal law.
The Chief Justice of the United States, John Roberts, dissented from the majority ruling and wrote in a concurring opinion that he would not have overturned Roe but would have upheld Mississippi’s legislation prohibiting abortions after 15 weeks. Roberts did not join the majority.
Who voted to overturn Roe v. Wade
Roe v. Wade, the landmark case from 1973 that recognised women’s constitutional right to abortion, was overturned by the United States Supreme Court on Friday, a decision that was condemned by President Joe Biden and that will dramatically change life of millions of women in the United States. This decision will also exacerbate growing tensions in a country that is already deeply polarised.
A Mississippi statute that was supported by Republicans that prohibits abortions after 15 weeks of pregnancy was maintained by the Supreme Court in a decision that was 6-3 and propelled by its conservative majority. The decision to overturn Roe was made by a vote of 5-4, with conservative Chief Justice John Roberts writing separately to say that he would have supported the Mississippi statute without going the further step of completely eliminating the Roe precedent.
The impact of the decision will be felt far beyond the high-security confines of the court, potentially reshaping the political landscape in November’s elections to determine whether or not Biden’s fellow Democrats maintain control of Congress, and signalling a new openness on the part of the justices to change other rights that have been recognised for a very long time.
The decision will also intensify the debate over the legitimacy of the court, which was once an unassailable cornerstone of the democratic system in the United States but is increasingly under scrutiny for its more aggressively conservative decisions on a range of issues. The debate will intensify as a result of the decision.
Justices Neil Gorsuch, Brett Kavanaugh, and Amy Coney Barrett, all of whom were chosen by President Trump, joined Justice Clarence Thomas, who had been selected by the first President Bush, in supporting the view expressed by Justice Alito. Chief Justice John Roberts, who was chosen to his position by former President George W. Bush, was the only person who agreed with the verdict. He would have restricted the decision to maintain the Mississippi legislation that was at issue in the case, which prohibited abortions after 15 weeks.
He referred to the ruling as “a substantial jolt to the legal system” and stated that the majority opinion, as well as the dissenting opinion, exhibited “a relentless freedom from doubt on the legal question that I cannot share.”
Which Supreme Court Justices Voted to Overturn Roe V. Wade?
Dobbs v. Jackson Women’s Health Organization was the case in which the Supreme Court upheld a law from Mississippi that prohibits abortions after the first 15 weeks of pregnancy. This is approximately two months earlier than what the Supreme Court has traditionally permitted based on precedent dating back to Roe.
The court’s conservative majority, which sided with Mississippi, stated that the Roe decision was egregiously incorrect in recognising a constitutional right to an abortion. This is an error that the court has continued to perpetuate in the decades after Roe v. Wade.
Alito’s opinion, which is 78 pages long and has an appendix that is 30 pages long, seems to leave no authority uncited as support for the proposition that there is no inherent right to privacy or personal autonomy in various provisions of the Constitution. In addition, there is no evidence that peoples’ reliance on the court’s abortion precedents over the past half-century should matter, and this seems to be the case throughout the entire document.
Alito used the example of the case Planned Parenthood v. Casey, which was decided in 1992 and affirmed the basic finding of Roe v. Wade. The judgement was written by Justices Sandra Day O’Connor, Anthony Kennedy, and David Souter, who were all appointed to the court by Republican presidents. Alito referred to the language in the Casey ruling in which he stated that “conceded” reliance interests were not truly implicated because the use of contraception might prevent practically all unwanted pregnancies.
As a direct result of the judgement made by the Supreme Court, which is connected to a new abortion law that is extremely restrictive in Mississippi, it is anticipated that about half of the states will either ban or severely restrict abortion. Tens of millions of people all around the country will be impacted by the rules, and some of them may be forced to travel between states in order to receive reproductive health care.
Proponents of abortion rights were quick to criticise the decision, while opponents of abortion rights lauded a result that they had been hoping for for a long time and working to ensure would occur. On Friday, demonstrators converged on the United States Supreme Court to voice their support for or opposition to a ruling that will overturn decades of precedent in the United States.